Why: User rulings 4 plus the P3 live evidence. The base library taught layout
standards but not how to work: no planning discipline (plan tool used in 2 of
31 tool runs), no retry-escalation rule (same failing call retried verbatim),
no check-API-first rule (phantom API calls), and nothing about edit
granularity - the P3 after-run showed one turn of 27 single-line edits plus a
self-review spiral (117 tools). The final-reply rewrite layer sees only
160-char summaries and fabricated chapters/promised unfinished work; with the
transcript now authoritative the working model already has full evidence, so
per ruling 4 the rewrite defaults off (kept as fallback when a work loop ends
with no user-facing text at all, plus opt-in setting).
Changes: new base.method module (plan-first for 3+ steps, switch approach
after two failures, check API signatures before scripting, batch edits with
multi_edit, persist to completion - never end on a promise, trace numbers/
dates/names back to source material or mark speculation, honest final
report); tool-description overrides for read_file/edit_file/grep/glob/
run_python/run_shell (dedicated tools over cat/sed, build pipeline for Word);
plan reminder now also nudges once when NO plan exists after several tool
turns (ignorable, once per run); runtime.composeFinal default true->false
with empty-body fallback.
Evidence: SELF - TestPlanlessNudgeFiresOnce (fires once, never repeats),
TestResolveSystemDefaultBase updated for the ninth base block; go vet +
go test ./... pass; live before/after on the golden task set recorded on the
phase04 task card per the policy clause.
Impact: Behavior-surface change only; no contract or storage changes.
weichen
merged commit 1a3fbfb3d8 into main2026-10-09 23:40:29 +00:00
Blocking a user prevents them from interacting with repositories, such as opening or commenting on pull requests or issues. Learn more about blocking a user.
摘要
P4（裁定 4）：工作方法提示词 + composeFinal 降级。Dev 任务卡 feature/agent-quality-phase04；主记录 §4 P4。
真实模型对照（before=P3 后 main，after=本构建）
未核实数字仍 10 个 → P5 事实一致性核查。
Evidence
go vet + go test ./... 全绿；组合 make test PASS（evidence 行 SELF）；真实模型对照 evidence 行 + 报告
.task/phase04-eval/after-p4.json。Impact
行为面变更（提示词/设置默认值）；无契约/存储变更。