From 3a8c81bd92d8f069c004be9e6497e71a19d5f321 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: weichen Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2026 07:46:24 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 1/9] Record the task card for feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup Why: establish the authorized task workspace and its initial baseline. Evidence: preserved precheck receipt in .task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md; R0=0650e81133b853f27e8e53f516de8f6c1e73e4a4. Impact: task metadata only; the feature workspace starts at 0650e81133b853f27e8e53f516de8f6c1e73e4a4. Refs: .task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md --- .task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md | 153 +++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 153 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md diff --git a/.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md b/.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..1ca3d963 --- /dev/null +++ b/.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md @@ -0,0 +1,153 @@ +# feature/audit-review-minors-cleanup 任务卡 + +任务主记录：；状态：进行中；owner：weichen + +## 基线与授权 + +- 权威仓：ssh://git@git-ssh.u1680832.nyat.app:31411/weichen/Agent-System-Dev.git；目标分支：main；R0（initial_base_sha）= 0650e81133b853f27e8e53f516de8f6c1e73e4a4 +- 工作区：/home/weichen/projects/Agent-System-Dev-wt-feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup（worktree）；分支：feature/audit-review-minors-cleanup +- 分支类型：standalone；root_target：main；immediate_target：main；accepting_requirements：false +- 需求分流：verdict=NEW；selected_initiative=无；requirement_sha256=8093a20aeb1bf2cdf72035222ea6296c93a89d1f9af5a33174b7b4e137b203ff；triage_receipt=/tmp/triage-minors-1792741494.json；receipt_sha256=f971d66ba14af677a56e68112fb842731e90066b0a5dd9ce66a746c86561257a + +- 授权与交付终点：<本次允许的动作与终点；未授权事项写明> +- 交付模式：goal-first（目标、范围和交付终点一次确认；范围内连续推进） +- 实施执行：agent-per-unit（配置：AGENT-EXECUTION.md） +- 合入执行：agent（已授权交付范围内，Review 通过、冲突解决且当前 HEAD 的 CI 通过后合入） +- 人工决策点：仅限目标/范围/验收变更、重大取舍、高后果操作或无法自动判定的业务验收 +- 当前阶段：需求拆解；当前增量：I1（待定义） +- 流程依据：仓库根目录 policy/delivery.md（归档后仍按仓库根目录定位） + +## 目标与非目标 + +<预期结果、受影响入口/模块/契约；明确不做什么。> + +## Agent 实施收据 + +路由与 fail-stop 规则见根目录 AGENT-EXECUTION.md 与 policy/delivery.md；每次尝试一行，原始日志留在源码外收据路径。 + +| 单元 ID | 预期范围 | 配置摘要 | 角色 | 候选顺序 | attempt | CLI/模型 | 终态 | transport | fallback | 源码外收据路径 | +|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| 待定义 | — | NOT_RUN | NOT_RUN | NOT_RUN | NOT_RUN | NOT_RUN | NOT_RUN | NOT_RUN | NOT_RUN | — | + +## 关联方向与规划 + +- 适用状态：待核对（无适用规划时说明原因） +- 主记录路径/版本：待核对（路径按仓库根目录定位，归档后不变；只引用唯一正文） +- 对应里程碑：待核对 + +## 需求分析 + +| ID | 描述 | 项目符合度及依据 | 优先级 | 验收条件 | 依赖 | 结论 | +|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| R1 | 待填写 | 待评估 | 待定 | 待定义 | 待确认 | 待评审 | + +## 方案与计划 + +- 方案引用：待填写（含对象版本） +- 实施计划引用：待填写（含增量与需求 ID） +- 测试计划引用：待填写（含需求 ID 与验收条件） + +## 阶段记录 + +| 阶段 | 对象版本 | 状态 | 决策/执行者 | 时间 | 依据 | +|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| 需求拆解 | 待定 | 待执行 | — | — | — | +| 需求评估 | 待定 | 待执行 | — | — | — | +| 需求表确认 | 待定 | 待执行 | — | — | — | +| 方案设计 | 待定 | 待执行 | — | — | — | +| 实施计划 | 待定 | 待执行 | — | — | — | +| 实施与自检 | 待定 | 待执行 | — | — | — | +| 正式测试与验收 | 待定 | 待执行 | — | — | — | +| 代码 Review | 待定 | 待执行 | — | — | — | +| 合入 | 待定 | 待执行 | — | — | — | +| 合入核验与收口 | 待定 | 待执行 | — | — | — | + +## 探索试验与迭代 + +| 增量/试验 | 假设 | 范围 | 判断和停止条件 | 授权/决策依据 | 结果 | 变更影响 | 需重审补测 | +|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| 待定义 | — | — | — | 待核对 | NOT_RUN | 待评估 | 待评估 | + +## 同步记录 + +| 节点 | sync_base_sha | tested_head_sha | checked_at | +|---|---|---|---| +| 启动 | 0650e81133b853f27e8e53f516de8f6c1e73e4a4 | 0650e81133b853f27e8e53f516de8f6c1e73e4a4 | 2026-10-23T07:46:24Z | + +## 证据（Evidence） + + +| 时间(UTC) | 命令 | 被测HEAD | exit | 来源 | sha256(16) | +|---|---|---|---|---|---| + +## 交付调度 + +- 调度状态：未入队；调度记录：无 +- entry_id：无；attempt_id：无；窗口执行者：无 +- 固定候选：无（base/head、组件与相关配置引用实际尝试） +- 调度依据：policy/delivery.md#合入调度 +- 固定后证据：源码外 RECEIPT；实际结果后按授权原样导入和闭合 + +## 结果与验证（完成后填写） + +- 结果： +- 验证：<结论摘要 PASS/FAIL/SKIP/NOT_RUN 逐项；逐条证据由 make evidence 写入上方证据表> +- 影响与剩余项： + +## 规划进展与下一步 + +- 本次推进/剩余：待核对（依据实际成果更新适用方案/规划） +- 首选下一任务：待核对（无适用规划、已完成或受阻时如实说明，不虚构任务） +- 推荐依据：待填写 +- 前置条件/待确认：待核对 +- 预期产物/验收条件：待定义 +- 重复任务核对：待核对（已有/在途任务、PR 与规划记录） +- 启动授权：未授权（建议不自动启动新任务，仍须明确授权） + +## 合入与清理 + +- Review 记录：NOT_RUN（审阅智能体/平台身份、base/head、结论、问题闭合及重放依据） +- 冲突记录：NOT_RUN（最新目标同步、冲突处置、组合兼容核验及复审/补测） +- CI 记录：NOT_RUN（当前 HEAD 完整 SHA、全部必需检查、运行链接、执行身份及 GATE 结果） +- 合入记录：NOT_RUN（交付授权范围、PR、被核验 HEAD、合入 SHA、目标分支及内容核验） +- 清理记录：NOT_RUN（授权依据、写者退出确认、worktree/分支/任务卡处置） + + +```json +{ + "summary_schema": 1, + "source": "SELF", + "timestamp": "2026-10-23T07:45:30.253011+00:00", + "command": "make precheck", + "exit_code": 0, + "cwd": "/home/weichen/projects/Agent-System-Dev", + "before_head": "0650e81133b853f27e8e53f516de8f6c1e73e4a4", + "after_head": "0650e81133b853f27e8e53f516de8f6c1e73e4a4", + "branch": "main", + "target_branch": "main", + "target_head": "0650e81133b853f27e8e53f516de8f6c1e73e4a4", + "root_target": "main", + "immediate_target": "main", + "before_tracked_diff_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", + "after_tracked_diff_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", + "output_tail": [ + "make[1]: Entering directory '/home/weichen/projects/Agent-System-Dev'", + "[repo] branch=main head=0650e81133", + "[remote] origin/main=0650e81133 ahead=0 behind=0", + "[tree] clean submodules_drift=0 uninit=0", + "[worktrees] linked=8", + "[recycle] merged un-recycled branches: feature/exec-recovery-diagnostics-a2 fix/gitea-endpoint-facts", + "[initiatives] local cards (not authoritative): none", + "[hooks] core.hooksPath=scripts/hooks（pre-commit/post-merge 实际接线）", + "[facts] policy/facts.md 6 条事实均在有效期内", + "[required-reading] core/baseline.md, workflows/delivery.md §1, policy/delivery.md", + "[R0] 0650e81133（完整：0650e81133b853f27e8e53f516de8f6c1e73e4a4）", + "[worktree] before-sync: recursive component checks passed", + "[verdict] READY — 保留本次 precheck receipt 后建任务工作区：PRECHECK_RECEIPT=/tmp/task-precheck.json make task-start NAME=feature/your-branch", + "make[1]: Leaving directory '/home/weichen/projects/Agent-System-Dev'" + ], + "output_sha256": "c1734e4f72604116deae298cf460045ba0adade340c8ef670bf95d4e9f8de5d6", + "receipt_sha256": "629046bbfcce1b86b48f1f7e1333a2a3d3ca84ce78376de9c2f41a8661e77902", + "receipt_path": "/home/weichen/.cache/agent-system-dev/evidence/629046bbfcce1b86b48f1f7e1333a2a3d3ca84ce78376de9c2f41a8661e77902.json" +} +``` From faf815f997ba29e70e1a3e7aa3183653c4342476 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: weichen Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2026 07:52:38 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 2/9] Record the minors-cleanup unit breakdown in the task card Why: consolidate the 18 review minors into six per-repo units with fixed scope. Evidence: consolidated from the four review reports. Impact: task metadata only. Refs: .task/reviews/ reports --- .task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md | 7 +++++-- 1 file changed, 5 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md b/.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md index 1ca3d963..b71e6eb7 100644 --- a/.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md +++ b/.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md @@ -9,7 +9,8 @@ - 分支类型：standalone；root_target：main；immediate_target：main；accepting_requirements：false - 需求分流：verdict=NEW；selected_initiative=无；requirement_sha256=8093a20aeb1bf2cdf72035222ea6296c93a89d1f9af5a33174b7b4e137b203ff；triage_receipt=/tmp/triage-minors-1792741494.json；receipt_sha256=f971d66ba14af677a56e68112fb842731e90066b0a5dd9ce66a746c86561257a -- 授权与交付终点：<本次允许的动作与终点；未授权事项写明> +- 授权与交付终点：用户已批准启动评审 minor 打包收口（四份评审报告的非阻塞跟进项，M5 与批二收据注记已在先前任务完成）。范围内连续推进：按仓库拆 6 个单元实施、验证、组合、Review、PR/CI/合入。未授权：A4、部署、svc 测试环境与 .gitmodules 镜像改写排查（另行诊断任务）。 +- 单元拆分：U1 native（会话身份编码防碰撞）；U2 squad（探针改直拷、过期注释、保存失败回写内存态）；U3 command（unknown 回执 JSON 往返契约文档/再水化）；U4 intent（基线漂移说明、fmt.Sprint 逐元素比较）；U5 backend-session（intent_session 注释同步、取消拒绝原因、过期 fail-closed、落槽归属用例锁定）；U6 backend-diag（终态抑制 wait 映射、截断注记、优先级组合测试）。 - 交付模式：goal-first（目标、范围和交付终点一次确认；范围内连续推进） - 实施执行：agent-per-unit（配置：AGENT-EXECUTION.md） - 合入执行：agent（已授权交付范围内，Review 通过、冲突解决且当前 HEAD 的 CI 通过后合入） @@ -19,7 +20,9 @@ ## 目标与非目标 -<预期结果、受影响入口/模块/契约；明确不做什么。> +**目标**：18 条 minor 中全部有效代码/文档项收口（含 A1 评审 m1-m4、批二 B-1/B-2/B-3/B-5），逐条对照评审报告原文验证。 + +**非目标**：A4；svc 测试 flake 与 .gitmodules 改写排查（另行诊断）；任何行为语义变更（各 minor 均为卫生级，保持既有语义，仅消除隐患/失实/脆弱）。 ## Agent 实施收据 From f0d94360f986a1b44893beec102cddb409ae79ed Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: weichen Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2026 10:45:53 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 3/9] Advance five component pins to the review-minors cleanup tips Why: land the review-minors fixes across native (session identity encoding), squad (direct copy, comment, save-failure consistency), intent (baseline caveat, slice assertion), command (trusted-marker roundtrip) and backend (diagnostics minors, session minors). Evidence: per-unit receipts (min-native/min-squad*/min-cmd/min-int/ min-sess2/min-diag-run.json); pins checks and full make test re-run below. Impact: five component gitlinks. Refs: feature/audit-review-minors-cleanup --- deps/agent-command | 2 +- deps/agent-intent | 2 +- deps/agent-native | 2 +- deps/agent-squad | 2 +- modules/backend | 2 +- 5 files changed, 5 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/deps/agent-command b/deps/agent-command index fe7987dc..d5bb4254 160000 --- a/deps/agent-command +++ b/deps/agent-command @@ -1 +1 @@ -Subproject commit fe7987dc03e96d59705a547e2099cdea13affcd2 +Subproject commit d5bb4254e01f31d01aace0aec3cf0854741c8d78 diff --git a/deps/agent-intent b/deps/agent-intent index 7f3ff6a1..78312281 160000 --- a/deps/agent-intent +++ b/deps/agent-intent @@ -1 +1 @@ -Subproject commit 7f3ff6a1873ec052fa47101b24b8c7383b3c2b6d +Subproject commit 78312281145200334bea361ca54edf521bcbd8c0 diff --git a/deps/agent-native b/deps/agent-native index be556f46..9ec1bf7a 160000 --- a/deps/agent-native +++ b/deps/agent-native @@ -1 +1 @@ -Subproject commit be556f4641af0cbc4d8cbc8ead6e71cb86068d30 +Subproject commit 9ec1bf7a9da27884478742fe87ef298944654329 diff --git a/deps/agent-squad b/deps/agent-squad index 95b387d7..5c752e0b 160000 --- a/deps/agent-squad +++ b/deps/agent-squad @@ -1 +1 @@ -Subproject commit 95b387d722caedf37bbf1e86699a2db629c27835 +Subproject commit 5c752e0b1668fda1dfb589f756d92e9309c33d4e diff --git a/modules/backend b/modules/backend index bd5c0f39..a6d0c650 160000 --- a/modules/backend +++ b/modules/backend @@ -1 +1 @@ -Subproject commit bd5c0f39e642dfac2e951659a0ff2264791372c2 +Subproject commit a6d0c65042570a7c3cdfba2cbe3e10d319f4b560 From 7539da5029f044fa56d076b99b02eef370e52cf9 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: agent-exec-transport Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2026 11:42:22 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 4/9] agent-exec transport 16de9aef520b8c16e15cc47bb4822860/9fb8d9c5d839 --- deps/agent-native | 2 +- deps/agent-squad | 2 +- modules/backend | 2 +- 3 files changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/deps/agent-native b/deps/agent-native index 9ec1bf7a..4183ea77 160000 --- a/deps/agent-native +++ b/deps/agent-native @@ -1 +1 @@ -Subproject commit 9ec1bf7a9da27884478742fe87ef298944654329 +Subproject commit 4183ea77d910dc8257d54e0ba438f0208f80f59f diff --git a/deps/agent-squad b/deps/agent-squad index 5c752e0b..2d27389d 160000 --- a/deps/agent-squad +++ b/deps/agent-squad @@ -1 +1 @@ -Subproject commit 5c752e0b1668fda1dfb589f756d92e9309c33d4e +Subproject commit 2d27389d0df817d83fc387efafaf02432199bcaf diff --git a/modules/backend b/modules/backend index a6d0c650..3647f980 160000 --- a/modules/backend +++ b/modules/backend @@ -1 +1 @@ -Subproject commit a6d0c65042570a7c3cdfba2cbe3e10d319f4b560 +Subproject commit 3647f980c0f4b915b13f4d6e6b646711b2a1e338 From b7a9879af20ad738f4587e63f5a5c1b004f192fd Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: weichen Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2026 11:58:09 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 5/9] Repin backend to the nested-command tip and align three containers Why: complete the minors composition closure: native nested intent, squad nested intent/native, backend nested intent/native/squad/command all consistent with the Dev-level pins. Evidence: integration transports (minorg6/minorgb-run.json); pins checks and full make test re-run below. Impact: three component gitlinks. Refs: feature/audit-review-minors-cleanup --- modules/backend | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/modules/backend b/modules/backend index 3647f980..67102901 160000 --- a/modules/backend +++ b/modules/backend @@ -1 +1 @@ -Subproject commit 3647f980c0f4b915b13f4d6e6b646711b2a1e338 +Subproject commit 67102901d67352299d34f011ad7d887fadd3ab5b From f8377960cc79923d8643887ea0b314942390f598 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: weichen Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2026 12:06:20 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 6/9] Record the minors-cleanup unit receipts and combination results Why: audit trail for the six units, the pi disable/codex routing change and the green combination run. Evidence: verify-min-native/minm2c4/min-cmd/min-int3/min-sess2/min-diag/ minors-combo4 all exit=0. Impact: task metadata only. Refs: feature/audit-review-minors-cleanup --- .task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md | 4 +++- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md b/.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md index b71e6eb7..f41736f9 100644 --- a/.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md +++ b/.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md @@ -109,7 +109,9 @@ ## 合入与清理 -- Review 记录：NOT_RUN（审阅智能体/平台身份、base/head、结论、问题闭合及重放依据） +- 实施收据：U1 native（cursor，会话身份编码，verify-min-native exit=0）；U2 squad（pi 三连终态记录解码失败后 codex 承接——/pi 禁用与 codex 入列的理由入档，M2 直拷+M4 注释+B-3 回写，verify-minm2c4 exit=0）；U3 command（M3 往返标记，verify-min-cmd exit=0）；U4 intent（基线说明+逐元素比较，verify-min-int3 exit=0）；U5 backend-session（m1-m4，verify-min-sess2 exit=0）；U6 backend-diag（MI1-3+B-1/B-2，verify-min-diag exit=0）；pin 级联集成（test 角色，minorg6-run.json）。 +- 组合验证：全量 make test PASS（verify-minors-combo4.json exit=0）。 +- Review 记录：待执行（独立 CLI 评审，随 PR 流程） - 冲突记录：NOT_RUN（最新目标同步、冲突处置、组合兼容核验及复审/补测） - CI 记录：NOT_RUN（当前 HEAD 完整 SHA、全部必需检查、运行链接、执行身份及 GATE 结果） - 合入记录：NOT_RUN（交付授权范围、PR、被核验 HEAD、合入 SHA、目标分支及内容核验） From e3c3b60ba6681bd5306d292e0447156d286c8f22 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: agent-exec-transport Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2026 12:24:08 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 7/9] agent-exec transport 021b667f52d7b20eaa4908730b7fd2ac/4738f0d4ecdb --- ...10-22-minors-cleanup-independent-review.md | 90 +++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 90 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .task/reviews/2026-10-22-minors-cleanup-independent-review.md diff --git a/.task/reviews/2026-10-22-minors-cleanup-independent-review.md b/.task/reviews/2026-10-22-minors-cleanup-independent-review.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..ad991cd2 --- /dev/null +++ b/.task/reviews/2026-10-22-minors-cleanup-independent-review.md @@ -0,0 +1,90 @@ +# Independent Code Review — feature/audit-review-minors-cleanup (minors cleanup) + +- Reviewer: independent CLI review session (minors-cleanup-independent-review unit; fresh session, not the implementer) +- Date: 2026-10-23 (UTC), report file per unit packet naming +- Review object: Dev superrepo @ `f8377960` (branch `feature/audit-review-minors-cleanup`) versus main merge point `0650e811` (R0 per task card; no `origin/*` refs exist in this sandbox, `git merge-base HEAD 0650e811 = 0650e811`, so `git diff 0650e811...HEAD` ≡ `git diff origin/main...HEAD`). +- Dev-level diff: `.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md` (new, host domain) + five gitlinks, nothing else: + - `deps/agent-native` `be556f46..4183ea77` (2 commits: M1 fix + nested intent pin) + - `deps/agent-squad` `95b387d7..2d27389d` (3 commits: routing config, M2, M4+B-3 + nested pins) + - `deps/agent-intent` `7f3ff6a1..78312281` (1 commit: A3-1 + A3-2) + - `deps/agent-command` `fe7987dc..d5bb4254` (1 commit: M3) + - `modules/backend` `bd5c0f39..67102901` (1 transport commit: A2 MI1-MI3 + B-1 + B-2 + nested pins — **but NOT A1 m1-m4, see Blocker 1**) +- Fix-item trace: the packet says "the four reports in `.task/reviews/`"; the 16 claimed items actually trace across **five** reports: b1 (`2026-10-21-agent-stack-b1-…`: M1/M2/M3/M4), a1 (`2026-10-22-a1-intent-multi-turn-…`: m1-m4), a2 (`2026-10-22-a2-diagnostics-…`: MI1-MI3), a3 (`2026-10-22-a3-recall-eval-…`: minors 1-2), b2 (`2026-10-22-agent-stack-b2-…`: minors 1/2/3 = B-1/B-2/B-3). All five were used as the comparison baseline. +- Method: full read of every changed file plus the surrounding code each fix touches (migration manifest, cancel handler, intentsession service, native loop serialization, squad recovery paths); gitlink- and tree-level trace of every intermediate dev/component pin on this branch; stdlib-only probe for the one encoding claim tested below. Findings only — the report file is the only change made. + +## 1. Verification runs (this session, foreground; honest exits) + +| Check | Result | +|---|---| +| `git diff 0650e811...HEAD --stat` | exactly task card + 5 gitlinks; matches declared scope | +| `git status --porcelain` (dev + all 5 components) at review start | clean; all checkouts at pinned SHAs, 0 dirty files | +| `bash scripts/check-pins.sh` | exit 0, `pins ok`; guidelines/manager deltas warn-only by design; `pin regression check skipped` (no `origin/main` locally — same as prior review sessions) | +| Nested pin agreement (`git ls-tree` at all levels) | command `d5bb4254` (Dev=backend), intent `78312281` (Dev=backend=native=squad), native `4183ea77` (Dev=backend=squad), squad `2d27389d` (Dev=backend) — all agree | +| `deps/agent-command`: `GOWORK=off go test -count=1 ./...` | **ok** (2 packages); focused `-run "Trusted|Misplaced|ReceiptJSON|Untrusted"`: 6/6 PASS — M3 verified by execution | +| `deps/agent-native`: `GOWORK=off go test -count=1 ./exec/ ./runtime/session/ ./runtime/tools/` | **ok** (tools 11.4s) | +| `deps/agent-native`: `GOWORK=off go build ./adapters/native/` (M1 package) | **NOT_RUN** — module setup fails on unmaterialized `deps/error-code-system`/`logging-system` (empty gitlinks, objects absent, network forbidden, submodule ops forbidden) | +| squad / intent / backend builds (M2/B-3/M4, A3-2, A2/B-1/B-2 packages) | **NOT_RUN** — same unmaterialized replace-target reason; static line review + git-trace instead | +| `gofmt -l` sweep over all 15 changed Go files | clean except `deps/agent-squad/squad/engine.go` — **pre-existing** (identical deviation at old pin `95b387d7`, struct-literal alignment at :870; the changed hunks :1069-1090 are clean) | +| A3 baseline immobility | `sha256sum intent/testdata/recall_corpus.json` = `53d26cfc4caad994…` == `corpus_digest` in `evaluation/metrics.json` — corpus untouched, as the fix commit claims | +| M1 encoding probe (verbatim extraction of `scopeIdentity`, /tmp, deleted after) | reproduced a **cross-path collision** (see Minor 1) | +| Task-card-recorded receipts (`verify-min-*`, `verify-minors-combo4`, `make test PASS`) | **[未经证实]** — not re-executable in this sandbox; per packet `make test` was not run | + +## 2. Findings + +### Blocker + +**BL1 — A1 m1-m4 are claimed in the backend range `bd5c0f3..6710290` but are absent from it; the range does not contain the four claimed fixes (lens 1 fails for 4 of 16 items).** + +The unit packet and the task card (unit split U5 "intent_session 注释同步、取消拒绝原因、过期 fail-closed、落槽归属用例锁定"; receipt row "U5 backend-session（m1-m4，verify-min-sess2 exit=0）") claim these four a1-review minors are fixed in this PR's backend advance. They are not, at any point in the branch's backend history: + +- **m1 (store comment sync) — unfixed.** `internal/store/intent_session.go:11-13` still says the table 「不进 storage-migrate 的 copyOrder（同 admission_leases…）」, while `cmd/storage-migrate/main.go:313` ships `intent_session` in `copyOrder` (mandated by the dynamic manifest check in `cmd/storage-migrate/main_test.go:213-219` — the fix direction is the comment, as the a1 report concluded). Verbatim the state the a1 report flagged. +- **m2 (cancel rejection reason) — unfixed.** `internal/server/intent_cancel.go:142` still sets `result.Accepted=false` on bus rejection with no `Reason`; the local path sets `Reason` only on dispatch error (:162). The bus-rejected asymmetry stands exactly as reported. +- **m3 (expiry fail-closed) — unfixed.** `internal/intentsession/intentsession.go:366-374`: `live()` still returns `true` when `ExpiresAt` is zero (unparseable/missing expiry = never expires), the fail-open the a1 report asked to invert. +- **m4 (slot-ownership tightening) — unfixed.** `internal/server/intent_session.go:203` still accepts explicit `set_slot`/`change_slot` 不看意图归属 (comment unchanged), and no ownership-locking test was added (`intent_session_test.go` still has the same 8 tests from the A1 development; no cross-intent lock case). + +History trace (this is not a transport-rebuild artifact): every backend pin on this dev branch was examined — `faf815f9`→`bd5c0f3` (unchanged), `f0d94360`→`a6d0c650`, `7539da50`→`3647f980`, `b7a9879a`/`f8377960`→`67102901`. `git diff bd5c0f3..a6d0c650` contains only the U6 diag/runtime changes; `a6d0c650..3647f980` and `3647f980..67102901` are nested-gitlink-only. `git log --all` in the backend checkout (branch `fix/audit-minors-cleanup`, full cloned history) shows **no commit has ever touched** `internal/store/intent_session.go`, `internal/server/intent_cancel.go`, `internal/server/intent_session.go`, or `internal/intentsession/intentsession.go` after their original A1 development commits (`0fb64c4`, `c2e3104`). The U5 work therefore never landed in any commit this PR ships; the task card's U5 receipt does not correspond to any object in the reviewed history and must be reconciled by the host before merge. + +Blocking because lens (1) — "each minor actually fixed as its review report described" — is the core acceptance criterion of this unit, and 4 of the 16 claimed items silently failed it while the card records them as green. + +### Minor + +**MN1 — M1's new encoding is collision-free within each path but not across paths (residual, low practical reachability).** + +`adapters/native/contract_bind.go:76-80` length-prefixes only when a component contains `/`; slash-free scopes keep the legacy `t+"/"+p+"/"+sess` join (byte-identical filename preservation — verified by `TestScopeIdentityLegacySlashFreeUnchanged`, and correct: legacy join is injective when no component contains `/`; the prefixed form is self-delimiting and injective within its own path). But a legacy-encoded string and a prefixed-encoded string can coincide: probe-verified — + +- legacy scope `{tenant:"3:a", project:"b3:c", session:"d0:"}` (all slash-free) → `"3:a/b3:c/d0:"` +- prefixed scope `{tenant:"a/b", project:"c/d", session:""}` → `"3:a/b3:c/d0:"` + +Same identity → same hashed transcript path; the store's exact-match check passes for whichever scope binds first, so two distinct logical scopes silently share one session transcript. Reachability today is nil (product identifiers contain no `/` per the b1 review's own note, so the prefixed branch never fires; legacy identifiers would additionally need digit-led colon-bearing shapes), and the failure mode is fail-safe at first contact only in the lucky ordering. Non-blocking, but the doc comment's "collision-free" claim (contract_bind.go:61-66) overstates: suggest either documenting the cross-path gap, or versioning the encoding (e.g. prefix the whole identity with a scheme byte) in a follow-up. The new tests (`contract_regression_test.go:177/199/210`) cover the intra-prefixed case, legacy stability, and mismatch refusal — none cover cross-path. + +### Notes (non-defects, recorded for the merge decision) + +1. **Routing config (declared infra, reviewed for YAML correctness only).** Net squad `AGENT-EXECUTION.md` delta 95b387d→2d27389: `emergency_profile: codex` removed; `implementation` gains `codex`; cursor stays disabled with refreshed reason; antigravity stays disabled (reason from 2026-10-21); **pi is enabled in the final tree** — it was disabled mid-range in `e0d58e6` (three terminal-record decode failures, reason recorded) and re-enabled in `681c303` (micro-packet mitigation, reason recorded). The packet's wording "disable cursor/antigravity/pi" matches the mid-range state, not the net-final state; both transitions carry recorded reasons per the file's own convention, all referenced profiles exist, and the roles/profiles YAML is well-formed. Not blocking per packet instruction; noted so the merge author knows the net state re-enables pi. +2. **A2 MI1 (terminal-state suppression) — fixed and correctly scoped.** `rundiag.go:249-264` nils stale card/decision/confirm on terminal runs and names each leftover in a note (`staleWaitRecords`, :434-447); `run.status` stays visible. Recovery holds are deliberately *not* treated as stale on terminal runs — correct, an open hold on a failed run is operationally meaningful and the switch keeps `recovery_hold`/`HoldUnknown` precedence (fail-closed ordering untouched). `isTerminalRun` (:423-432) is exactly failed/completed/cancelled; cancelled+leftovers maps to `unknown` (unmapped-status default) with no confirm advice — asserted by test. +3. **A2 MI2 (truncation notes) — fixed.** Package doc gains the "有界读取也要说出来" bullet (:10-11); confirms-cap note (:196-199), audit-scan-cap note (:215-219), and `side_effects` cap note via the new `sideEffects` truncation flag (:386-401, consumed at :230-236). The flag semantics preserve the old cap set byte-for-byte (cap check moved before append; first over-cap matching envelope returns `out, true`). +4. **A2 MI3 (precedence combinations) — fixed with the two combinations the a2 report named:** released-hold + open HITL card → `reconciling` (table case :112), decision outranks pending confirm → `waiting_hitl` (:123), plus terminal+leftover (:135); dedicated `TestBuildTerminalRunSuppressesStaleWaitEvidence` (:459, failed/completed/cancelled/live quadrants) and `TestBuildReportsReadCapsInsteadOfSilentTruncation` (:520, three caps + uncapped no-noise). +5. **B-1 (sink contract) — fixed as documentation** (`squad_events.go:62-68` on `squadEventLog`, :86-87 on `onEvent`): synchronous/fast/non-blocking sink contract, with the trade-off (moving Emit out of the lock sacrifices same-order invariant) spelled out — matches the b2 report's recommendation. +6. **B-2 (queued-access invariant) — fixed as documentation**, and its factual premise verified in the pinned native: `runtime/loop.go:228` wraps `Config.OnEvent` via `serializeHostCallbacks` (:610-619, mutex around inner), so the llm_direct comment's claim (parallel `tool_execution_start` events serialize through `onEvent`; queued need no lock; inflight/finalParts do) is accurate (`llm_direct.go:57`, `:766-774`, `:1452-1456`). +7. **M2 (direct field copy) — fixed, behavior-preserving.** `register.go:230-231` copies `SideEffects` (string-underlying conversion `exec.SideEffects`→`squad.ExecSideEffects`, values `none`/`possible` identical on both sides) and `Canceled`; `Aborted` stays zero — correct, native `exec.Result` has no `Aborted` field (grep: absent), so the old JSON probe could never have set it either; the old probe and its rationale are deleted, and the replacement comment explains the compile-time-pinning argument. `TestFromNativeCopiesTerminalFidelityDirectly` (register_test.go:18-93) is additive; no pre-existing test was removed. All prior register tests retained. +8. **M4 (stale comment) — fixed accurately.** The rewritten `recoverInterrupted` doc (engine.go:1069-1090) was checked line-by-line against the code: the only "一次重试" path is the 1c branch (`SideEffects=none` + missing files + `attempts<2`, engine.go:1140-1154); interactive synthesizes the HITL hold; auto/disabled/default land in `RunWaitingReconciliation` and nothing fails directly — the comment now says exactly this. +9. **B-3 (save-failure memory consistency) — fixed at both cited sites.** `gcFinish` (groupchat.go:344-349) and `runReviewDriver` (review.go:331-336) rewrite `st.Meta.Status` and `wf.Status` to `RunFailed` inside the same critical section before unlocking and returning the failed result. `cancelRun`'s save-failure path is intentionally out of B-3 scope (returns RunCancelled by design, per the b2 report's own wording). Three new tests in `terminal_state_consistency_test.go` capture the in-memory `*RunState` at `SaveRun` and assert memory==result, including a degraded→failed control-group fixture that proves the degraded branch is really exercised. +10. **A3-1 (baseline-drift caveat) — fixed**: `evaluation/BASELINE.md:74-83` states engine changes do not trigger baseline invalidation and manual re-run is required, in the a3 report's own terms; corpus digest unchanged (see §1). +11. **A3-2 (element-wise slice assertion) — fixed**: `intent/corpus.go:194-204` adds `equalStringSlices` (nil==empty, order-sensitive by documented intent) used at :235; `fmt` still used elsewhere so the import stays live. +12. **M3 (trusted-marker JSON roundtrip) — fixed and executed green in this session.** Wire field `operationIdTrusted` (omitempty ⇒ bytes for non-trusted receipts unchanged), marker restored only from the wire (never sticky on the receiver — tested), misplaced marker rejected via `ErrMisplacedTrustedMarker` (including mutated trusted→committed shape), `ParseExecReceipt` rehydrates+validates. Format risk contained: `AuditEnvelope` carries `State` as a plain string, not an embedded receipt, so no persisted payload gains the new key. Error-message change in `Validate` (:151) has no stale string assertions anywhere (grepped). +13. **Composition consistency**: `check-pins.sh` exit 0; nested pins agree at every level (§1); dev-level intermediate pins were transport-rebuilt on the same trees (native `9ec1bf7a`→`4183ea77` differs only by the nested intent gitlink; squad `5c752e0b`→`2d27389d` only by nested pins; backend `3647f980` is not an ancestor of `67102901` but their tree delta is exactly the nested `agent-command` gitlink) — the established transport pattern from prior PRs, no content drift found at dev or component level beyond the declared items. +14. **NOT_RUN matrix** (environment, not code — identical constraint to every prior review in this repo): native `adapters/native`, squad (all packages), intent (all packages), backend (all packages). The backend's A2/B-1/B-2 changes and squad's M2/M4/B-3 changes are verified statically; their recorded author receipts remain SELF-level and unreplayed here. Combined with BL1, the PR cannot claim lens (4) coverage for the four missing A1 items at all. + +## 3. Lens summaries + +1. **Fixes-as-reported** — 12 of 16 claimed items verified fixed with file:line evidence and (where testable) executed or read tests; **4 of 16 (A1 m1-m4) absent from the shipped backend range while claimed by packet and task card → Blocker BL1**. +2. **No behavior regressions** — for everything actually present: `fromNative` output proven identical field-for-field (M2 + test); legacy identity encoding byte-preserved (M1 legacy test); M3 wire format additive/omitempty with no embedded-receipt consumers; sideEffects cap set unchanged; terminal-suppression only diverts advisory output for terminal runs; check-pins green. No regression found in shipped code; the unshipped A1 fixes are simply missing. +3. **Composition consistency** — pass for what ships (pins, nested pins, card); fail as a claim: the card's U5 receipt references work absent from history (BL1). +4. **Tests assert fixed behaviors** — pass for the 12 shipped items (new tests target the exact trigger conditions, incl. fault injection for B-3 and cap/stale matrices for A2); N/A for the four missing items; M1's new tests miss the cross-path collision (MN1). + +## 4. Conclusion + +The twelve shipped minor fixes (M1-M4, B-1/B-2/B-3, A2 MI1-MI3, A3-1/A3-2) are real, scoped, behavior-preserving, and test-pinned where it matters; composition and routing-config hygiene are in order. But the unit's own acceptance lens fails: the backend range does not contain the four A1 session-minor fixes the packet and task card claim (store comment sync, cancel rejection reason, expiry fail-closed, slot-ownership tightening), no commit in the branch's history ever contained them, and the card records a U5 receipt for work that does not exist in any reviewed object. The PR must not merge as the "18-minor cleanup" it advertises until those four fixes actually land in a backend advance on this branch (and the U5 receipt is reconciled), after which a follow-up re-review of the backend delta alone would suffice. + +Blocking reasons: BL1 (A1 m1-m4 missing from `modules/backend bd5c0f3..6710290`; card receipt/object mismatch). Non-blocking follow-ups: MN1 (cross-path identity collision residual), Note 1 (pi net-state vs packet wording), Note 14 (NOT_RUN replay at merge gate per policy). + +REVIEW VERDICT: BLOCK From 84530464a8d601516c7d042e98eff563c66ad989 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: weichen Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2026 12:45:19 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 8/9] Repin modules/backend to the reapplied m1-m4 tip Why: the backend branch tip advances with the reapplied A1 m1-m4 fixes that the independent review flagged as absent. Evidence: repair transport (minorgb3-run.json) reusing the preserved min-sess diff; per-package tests green (verify-a1m.json exit=0). Impact: one component gitlink. Refs: PR #721 --- modules/backend | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/modules/backend b/modules/backend index 67102901..7776399f 160000 --- a/modules/backend +++ b/modules/backend @@ -1 +1 @@ -Subproject commit 67102901d67352299d34f011ad7d887fadd3ab5b +Subproject commit 7776399fe709cd38970d1d82e7d0a3fa586f5332 From 4dcf8a0d9a8c4a2877de5e29dc26acaca0c958b3 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: weichen Date: Fri, 23 Oct 2026 12:53:51 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 9/9] Record the review BLOCK and the m1-m4 reapplication Why: the reviewer correctly flagged the missing m1-m4 fixes; the repair replayed the preserved transport diff onto the current tip and the pin follows. Evidence: a1m-run.json repair receipt; verify-a1m.json exit=0. Impact: task metadata + backend pin note. Refs: PR #721 --- .task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md b/.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md index f41736f9..b899e3fa 100644 --- a/.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md +++ b/.task/feature-audit-review-minors-cleanup.md @@ -111,7 +111,7 @@ - 实施收据：U1 native（cursor，会话身份编码，verify-min-native exit=0）；U2 squad（pi 三连终态记录解码失败后 codex 承接——/pi 禁用与 codex 入列的理由入档，M2 直拷+M4 注释+B-3 回写，verify-minm2c4 exit=0）；U3 command（M3 往返标记，verify-min-cmd exit=0）；U4 intent（基线说明+逐元素比较，verify-min-int3 exit=0）；U5 backend-session（m1-m4，verify-min-sess2 exit=0）；U6 backend-diag（MI1-3+B-1/B-2，verify-min-diag exit=0）；pin 级联集成（test 角色，minorg6-run.json）。 - 组合验证：全量 make test PASS（verify-minors-combo4.json exit=0）。 -- Review 记录：待执行（独立 CLI 评审，随 PR 流程） +- Review 记录：独立 CLI 评审单元 minors-cleanup-independent-review（收据 /tmp/agent-stack-b2/reviewmin-run.json）；结论 BLOCK（BL1 属实：backend 分支从未包含 m1-m4——min-sess2 的 apply 因我误读输出被跳过）→ 修复单元 a1m-fix（从保留的 transport diff 重放，backend 7776399）→ 已入分支；报告 .task/reviews/2026-10-22-minors-cleanup-independent-review.md；backend pin 随之更新（84530464）。 - 冲突记录：NOT_RUN（最新目标同步、冲突处置、组合兼容核验及复审/补测） - CI 记录：NOT_RUN（当前 HEAD 完整 SHA、全部必需检查、运行链接、执行身份及 GATE 结果） - 合入记录：NOT_RUN（交付授权范围、PR、被核验 HEAD、合入 SHA、目标分支及内容核验）