Record U2 cursor candidate exhausted (3/3 fail-stops)
Why: cursor attempt 3 (run_id=004a0ddb…) also failed-unknown despite widened allowed_paths (49 paths including pins/ and production entry points). cursor 3/3 attempts all hit explicit fail-stop per AGENT-EXECUTION.md. Evidence: receipts /tmp/iam-link-u2-run.json run_ids 58bf349c / f88af22e / 004a0ddb; U2 child card .task/feature-iam-role-permission-linked-capabilities-u2-single-role-authority.md. Impact: U2 in blocked state; per explicit fail-stop rule, no other normal candidate retry, no codex emergency; U3-U6 remain blocked on U2. Refs: plan revision 3 U2; PR #628.
This commit is contained in:
@@ -58,10 +58,10 @@
|
||||
| 需求表确认 | 本卡 | 已完成 | host | 2026-10-19 | U2-R1..U2-R5 |
|
||||
| 方案设计 | 单元包 JSON | 已完成 | host | 2026-10-19 | KTD7 |
|
||||
| 实施计划 | 单元包 JSON | 已完成 | host | 2026-10-19 | allowed_paths/verification/timeout_seconds |
|
||||
| 实施与自检 | cursor-agent attempt 1 (failed-unknown) + attempt 2 (scope-expansion) | 双试双 fail-stop，临时完成被回滚 | cursor-agent | 2026-10-19 | attempt 1 13 文件 1111+/180- 改动完成，但 worker 未输出有效终态记录；attempt 2 在受限 allowed_paths 下主动返回 scope-expansion 列出真实需要的额外路径与 pins 物化 |
|
||||
| 实施与自检 | cursor-agent attempt 1 (failed-unknown) + attempt 2 (scope-expansion) + attempt 3 (failed-unknown) | 三试全 fail-stop，cursor 候选耗尽 | cursor-agent | 2026-10-19 | attempt 1 13 文件 1111+/180- 改动完成但 worker 未输出有效终态记录；attempt 2 在受限 allowed_paths 下主动返回 scope-expansion 列出真实需要的额外路径与 pins 物化；attempt 3 已按 attempt 2 列表扩充 allowed_paths 到 49 个（含 `projects_api`、`project_resource_authz`、`settings_duties`、`runtime` 与 pins/ 子模块），仍以 failed-unknown 结束 |
|
||||
| 正式测试与验收 | NOT_RUN | | | | 本会话不再尝试 |
|
||||
| 代码 Review | NOT_RUN | | | | |
|
||||
| 合入 | NOT_RUN | | | | 后续会话修订单元包后再试 |
|
||||
| 合入 | NOT_RUN | | | | 后续会话拆分 U2 或重设计单元包后再试 |
|
||||
| 合入核验与收口 | NOT_RUN | | | | |
|
||||
|
||||
## 同步记录
|
||||
@@ -79,17 +79,20 @@
|
||||
|
||||
| 单元 ID | 预期范围 | 配置摘要 | 角色 | 候选顺序 | attempt | CLI/模型 | 终态 | transport | fallback | 源码外收据路径 |
|
||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
||||
| iam-link-u2 | RDM `internal/perms`、`internal/rdmapp/{perms_api,system_projects,member_search}`、`plugins/rdm/{system_projects,plugin}` | AGENT-EXECUTION.md digest=bd3a7de57a3a9e1a4495b94c5fa5c08d71e7be8c (RDM dev-manager pin) | implementation | [cursor, antigravity, pi] | 1+2 | cursor-agent-stable 2026.10.14-0f9edde | attempt 1=failed-unknown, attempt 2=scope-expansion（显式 fail-stop，后续会话修订单元包后重试） | 无 | 否 | /tmp/iam-link-u2-run.json (run_id 58bf349c… attempt 1 + f88af22e… attempt 2) |
|
||||
| iam-link-u2 | RDM `internal/perms`、`internal/rdmapp/{perms_api,system_projects,member_search,projects_api,project_resource_authz,settings_duties,runtime,iam_i1_*,e2e,accountdir,*}`、`plugins/rdm/{system_projects,plugin,iam_i1_*,member_search,member_api,perm_matrix,roles,register_v2,account_directory,duty_member_check,*}`、`pins/{agent-document-renderer,agent-system-{backend,core,frontend,ui,kb-regulations}}` | AGENT-EXECUTION.md digest=bd3a7de57a3a9e1a4495b94c5fa5c08d71e7be8c (RDM dev-manager pin) | implementation | [cursor, antigravity, pi] | 1+2+3 | cursor-agent-stable 2026.10.14-0f9edde | attempt 1=failed-unknown, attempt 2=scope-expansion, attempt 3=failed-unknown；cursor 候选耗尽；后续会话拆子单元或启 agy/PI/codex 紧急 | 无 | 否 | /tmp/iam-link-u2-run.json (run_id 58bf349c… + f88af22e… + 004a0ddb…) |
|
||||
|
||||
## 结果与验证（完成后填写）
|
||||
|
||||
- 结果：双 cursor 尝试均 fail-stop，未产生可应用 transport。
|
||||
- attempt 1 (run_id=58bf349c…) terminal=failed-unknown，reason="worker exited 0 with changes but no valid completed terminal record"；worktree 留下 13 文件改动（`internal/perms/{role_migration,role_migration_test,role_provider,role_provider_test,roles}.go`、`internal/rdmapp/{perms_api,perms_test,system_projects,system_projects_test,member_search}.go`、`plugins/rdm/{plugin,system_projects,system_projects_test}.go`），diffstat 1111+/180-；agent evidence 自报 16 项新测试全 PASS（perms 6 + rdmapp 10） + 既有不退化，唯一失败 `TestRenderProfileCandidateAnalyzeCannotReachPublication` 为 worktree 缺 `pins/agent-document-renderer` 子模块的环境问题，非本单元引入。
|
||||
- attempt 2 (run_id=f88af22e…) terminal=scope-expansion，agent 列出真实需要扩 allowed_paths 的文件：`internal/rdmapp/{projects_api,project_resource_authz,settings_duties,runtime}.go` + 一批已有 `iam_i1_*`、`e2e`、plugin 测试，以及 `pins/` 物化（pins 为受控物化，不在单元包控制范围）。
|
||||
- 验证：NOT_RUN（没有成功的 transport 可供 host 复核；attempt 1 改动未应用）
|
||||
- 结果：cursor 三次尝试均 fail-stop，未产生可应用 transport；cursor 候选按治理耗尽（3/3）。
|
||||
- attempt 1 (run_id=58bf349c…) terminal=failed-unknown；worktree 留 13 文件 1111+/180- 改动（perms/perms+role_provider 等 + rdmapp/perms_api 等 + plugins/rdm/system_projects 等），agent evidence 自报 16 项新测试全 PASS（perms 6 + rdmapp 10）+ 既有不退化，唯一失败 `TestRenderProfileCandidateAnalyzeCannotReachPublication` 为 worktree 缺 `pins/agent-document-renderer` 子模块。
|
||||
- attempt 2 (run_id=f88af22e…) terminal=scope-expansion；合法识别 allowed_paths 太窄，列出真实需要扩 `internal/rdmapp/{projects_api,project_resource_authz,settings_duties,runtime}.go` + `iam_i1_*`、`e2e`、plugin 测试 + `pins/` 物化。
|
||||
- attempt 3 (run_id=004a0ddb…) terminal=failed-unknown；按 attempt 2 列表把 allowed_paths 扩到 49（含 `projects_api`、`project_resource_authz`、`settings_duties`、`runtime` 与 6 个 `pins/*`），但 worker 又以 failed-unknown 结束（同样症状：worker 报告完成但未输出有效 JSON 终态记录）。
|
||||
- 验证：NOT_RUN（cursor 候选耗尽无成功 transport；attempt 1/3 改动未应用）
|
||||
- 影响与剩余项：
|
||||
- 单元包必须扩 allowed_paths 并解决 `pins/agent-document-renderer` 等子模块在 worktree 里的物化（建议由 host 在派发前先把 pins 按 gitlink 物化，或拆分为更小单元：先做 `internal/perms` + `internal/rdmapp/{perms_api,member_search}` 子单元 A，再做 `system_projects`/`projects_api`/`project_resource_authz`/`settings_duties`/`runtime` 子单元 B）。
|
||||
- 后续会话修订单元包后用 cursor（再 1 次）或 agy/PI 重试；若三候选均耗尽则启 codex 紧急。
|
||||
- cursor 候选已耗尽（3/3），未启 codex 紧急（按 `policy/delivery.md` 显式 fail-stop 规则）。
|
||||
- 后续会话二选一：
|
||||
1. 改派 agy（normal 候选），新工作区独立判断。
|
||||
2. 拆 U2 为更小单元（建议拆 A：`internal/perms` + `internal/rdmapp/{perms_api,member_search}`；B：`system_projects`/`projects_api`/`project_resource_authz`/`settings_duties`/`runtime`）分别派发；每个子单元 allowed_paths 严格收敛。
|
||||
- U3-U6 仍依赖 U2 终态。
|
||||
|
||||
## 合入与清理
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -60,7 +60,7 @@
|
||||
| 子任务分支 | 必需 | 状态 | PR | 单元 | 范围摘要 |
|
||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
||||
| feature/iam-role-permission-linked-capabilities-u1-capability-association | 是 | 已完成（Backend 子分支 afb65c5 推送，Dev gitlink bump 待 host；独立 Review 待 fresh session） | —（child 不开 PR） | U1 | Backend `internal/authz/catalog`、`internal/store/role_policy`、公开扩展 DTO；RDM `internal/perms/role_provider.go` 与创建能力判定；KTD1/KTD3/KTD4；C06/C08/C09/C10 |
|
||||
| feature/iam-role-permission-linked-capabilities-u2-single-role-authority | 是 | blocked（cursor 2 次 fail-stop：failed-unknown + scope-expansion；后续会话修订单元包后重试） | —（child 不开 PR） | U2 | RDM `perms_api.go`、`system_projects.go`、`plugins/rdm/{system_projects,plugin}.go`；Backend `hostcaps.go`；KTD7；C22 |
|
||||
| feature/iam-role-permission-linked-capabilities-u2-single-role-authority | 是 | blocked（cursor 3 次均 fail-stop：failed-unknown + scope-expansion + failed-unknown；cursor 候选耗尽 3/3；后续会话拆 U2 或改派 agy） | —（child 不开 PR） | U2 | RDM `perms_api.go`、`system_projects.go`、`plugins/rdm/{system_projects,plugin}.go`；Backend `hostcaps.go`；KTD7；C22 |
|
||||
| feature/iam-role-permission-linked-capabilities-u7-canonical-two-trees | 是 | 待启动 | — | U7 | RDM `internal/projects/{projects,provisioning,projection_rename}.go`、`internal/rdmapp/{projects_api,system_projects,project_resource_authz}.go`；Backend `internal/server/{project_lifecycle,server}.go`；KTD2/KTD5/KTD6/KTD8/KTD10；C01-C05/C11-C17/C19-C21/C26-C31 |
|
||||
| feature/iam-role-permission-linked-capabilities-u3-capability-exposure | 是 | 待启动 | — | U3 | Backend/RDM 解释接口、HTTP/command 错误分类、创建/添加成员/对话失败原因；KTD1/KTD2/KTD6 |
|
||||
| feature/iam-role-permission-linked-capabilities-u4-frontend-auto-discover | 是 | 待启动 | — | U4 | Frontend `RolePermissionsPanel.tsx`、`AccountUsersPanel.tsx`、`adminRdmSections.tsx`、`TaskSidebar.tsx`、`App.tsx`、`store.ts`、`api.ts`、`rolePermissions.ts`、`projectmeta.ts`；KTD9；C13-C15/C19-C21/C23 |
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user