Record the user ruling to gate U6 on owner experience

Why: The U6 precondition (benefit evidence from U4/U5) resolves to the owner actually using the landed U1-U5 capability - the human usability comparison marked NOT_RUN since U1 finds its execution path here; the user ruled 2026-10-11 to evaluate first and decide U6 after. Evidence: Ruling collected via the session question panel on 2026-10-11; U1-U5 all merged (Dev #329/#336/#345/#351/#367). Impact: Documents-only (master record U6 gate note + index status). Refs: r2 U6 clause; Dev task feature/generative-ui-u6-gate-record EOF )
Merge pull request 'Record the user approval of the U5 action scope' (#71 ) from feature/generative-ui-u5 into main
2026-10-11 15:01:08 +00:00 · 2026-10-11 14:09:47 +00:00 · 2026-10-11 14:09:20 +00:00 · 2026-10-11 13:50:14 +00:00
3 changed files with 20 additions and 4 deletions
@@ -417,6 +417,11 @@ AG-UI 仅在需要跨 Agent 框架互通时评估事件适配；MCP Apps 仅在

 ### U6. 自适应任务与项目工作区

+> **2026-10-11 用户裁定**：U1–U5 已全部落地合入；U6 启动前置（「U4/U5 的收益
+> 与可靠性证据」）改为 **owner 实际体验评估**——在真实使用中启用 generative-ui
+> 插件、体验页面生成/修订/表单提交（人类可用性对照自 U1 起 NOT_RUN，本裁定即
+> 其执行方式）。体验结论（继续/调整/停止）由用户给出后再开 U6。
+
 - 关联 R8，依赖 U4/U5 的收益与可靠性证据。
 - 文件范围：Frontend workspace/任务页容器、插件上下文选择与触发策略、Backend 授权聚合适配、相关测试。
 - 方法：先当前任务，后项目；任务阶段触发有限更新；固定布局/恢复原视图；自动模式单独 opt-in。
@@ -2,8 +2,8 @@
 title: Generative UI U5 action-scope proposal
 date: 2026-10-11
 type: feat
-revision: r1
-status: awaiting-user-review
+revision: r2
+status: approved
 product_contract_source: generative-ui-r2-U5-clause
 ---

@@ -75,7 +75,18 @@ MCP/外部 HTTP 直连、任意命令即时全开。
 5. 禁用后动作 403；A 类本地行为不受影响。
 6. 幂等重放返回相同回执（并发双击一次生效）。

-## 六、请用户裁定的三点
+## 六、裁定记录（2026-10-11，用户已裁定）
+
+三点均经用户裁定**同意**（推荐项全取）：
+
+1. **分类与范围**：A 全开 / B 机制先行白名单空起步 / C 限插件自有写 / D 全关——同意。
+2. **C 类边界**：限定 KV + 后台任务台账，不建新业务事实表——同意。
+3. **确认卡 UX**：复用现有内联确认卡，不新建审批 UI——同意。
+
+本文升级为已批准范围；U5 实施按 policy/delivery.md 开任务（feature/generative-ui-u5），
+验收线以第五节为准。
+
+### 七、原裁定请求（历史留档）

 1. **分类与范围**：A 全开、B 机制先行白名单空起步、C 限插件自有写、D 全关——是否同意？
 2. **C 类边界**：插件自身写是否限定为 KV + 后台任务台账（不建新的业务事实表）？
@@ -6,7 +6,7 @@

 ## 先看哪一份

-待用户裁定：[Generative UI U5 动作范围提案](2026-10-11-generative-ui-u5-action-scope.md)（2026-10-11）。
+U5 已实施合入（动作闭环，Dev #367）；[U5 动作范围提案 r2](2026-10-11-generative-ui-u5-action-scope.md) 为已批准范围。U6 经用户 2026-10-11 裁定：待 owner 实际体验 U1–U5 产物（人类可用性对照的执行方式）后再定启动。
 r2 U5 条款要求先评审动作范围；本文给出 A/B/C/D 分类、审批挂接（复用既有 DangerHigh 确认卡与
 幂等）、排除项与验收线，待三点裁定后 U5 实施另行开任务。
Author	SHA1	Message	Date
weichen	b6b6059222	Record the user ruling to gate U6 on owner experience Why: The U6 precondition (benefit evidence from U4/U5) resolves to the owner actually using the landed U1-U5 capability - the human usability comparison marked NOT_RUN since U1 finds its execution path here; the user ruled 2026-10-11 to evaluate first and decide U6 after. Evidence: Ruling collected via the session question panel on 2026-10-11; U1-U5 all merged (Dev #329/#336/#345/#351/#367). Impact: Documents-only (master record U6 gate note + index status). Refs: r2 U6 clause; Dev task feature/generative-ui-u6-gate-record EOF )	2026-10-11 15:01:08 +00:00
weichen	75ddd65c69	Merge pull request 'Record the user approval of the U5 action scope' (#71 ) from feature/generative-ui-u5 into main	2026-10-11 14:09:47 +00:00
weichen	aba1d6a3d6	Record the user approval of the U5 action scope Why: The user ruled on the three questions (categories and ranges approved as proposed; C-class limited to plugin KV plus task ledger; confirm UX reuses the inline card); the proposal becomes the approved scope and unblocks the U5 implementation task. Evidence: Ruling collected via the session question panel on 2026-10-11; implementation task feature/generative-ui-u5 starts under policy/delivery.md. Impact: Documents-only (proposal r2 + index status). Refs: r2 master record U5; Dev task feature/generative-ui-u5 EOF )	2026-10-11 14:09:20 +00:00
weichen	72a098a783	Merge pull request 'Propose the U5 action scope for user review' (#70 ) from feature/generative-ui-u5-scope into main	2026-10-11 13:50:14 +00:00